Real cases
A case · you decide
Literal and Idiom at the train station
Idiom & Literal — a 16-year-old translating a German exchange student's message
The message says: "Ich verstehe nur Bahnhof." Word for word: "I understand only train station."
Literal is faithful to every word, and the result is nonsense in English.
Idiom asks what the saying means: it is what German speakers say when something makes no sense to them.
What is the best English translation?
Translate what a saying means, not what it says.
A case · you decide
Boomerang and Drift catch a change of tone
Boomerang & Drift — a 17-year-old checking a message she translated into Spanish
Luisa translated a casual text to her friend's grandmother, "Hey, can you give me a hand?", as "¿Podría usted ayudarme?" Back into English it reads "Could you help me?"
Boomerang sends the phrase back to see what returned.
Drift names what shifted: the meaning is the same, and the tone moved from friendly to formal.
Is the translation right?
A translation keeps more than words. Tone is part of what gets carried.